Site icon FJP Law Offices

Today’s Legal Enlightenment (Tuesday, 31 January 2023)

Share this article

THE EXECUTOR (THE TOOL) IS NOT THE DOER AND CANNOT BE CRIMINALIZED

The person who orders the action is called a vigeur (power) in the Penal Code, and they are regular perpetrators in the Netherlands.

Examples cited by Remmelink in his conclusion on the judgment of 18 June 1968): H. R. of 3 and 18 December 1849; 12 February 1850, W. 1130:

. . . A father orders his immature son to dig lignite without a permit.” H. R.: You are the doer. A mere child. The Dutch Code, which was born at the end of the 19th century – because the spirit of naturalism influenced it– presupposes that an event where the perpetrator does not act alone and in accordance with that must be provided with a name and mentions it “ordered to do.” It wasn’t impossible then – see M.v.T. – that legislators want to continue the real line: the employer is the “perpetrator,” meanwhile *the executor (tool) cannot be subject to criminal punishment because they are no longer the perpetrator.*

Source:  Book by Mr. J.M. van Bemmelen, entitled: Criminal Law 1 Material Criminal Law General Section, Publisher: Binacipta, page 274.

Best regards,

Fredrik J. Pinakunary


Share this article
Exit mobile version